You’re standing in the dairy aisle with five minutes to shop and a cart already full—granola for your kid, spinach for tonight, coffee you forgot last time. The yogurt case hums like a server room: regular, Greek, skyr; vanilla, honey, “Icelandic-style,” protein numbers shouting from every lid. You grab one, flip it over, hesitate. Will this cup actually keep you full—or just taste good for three bites?
Here’s the simple truth behind all those choices: Every yogurt begins the same way: pasteurized milk plus live bacterial cultures. During fermentation, those cultures nibble at lactose and create lactic acid—the tang you recognize. Where styles split is straining. Regular yogurt may be lightly strained or not at all, while Greek and skyr are strained more thoroughly to drain off liquid whey. That one step shifts everything you notice in the spoon: nutrition, thickness, and tang.(1) (2) (3).
“When clients want a higher-protein snack that actually keeps them full, I point them toward strained yogurts,” says Joanna Gregg, a MyFitnessPal dietitian. “I also recommend unsweetened or plain varieties. With these it’s easy to build your own flavor with fruit, spices, or a drizzle of honey without the unnecessary added carbs and sugar.”
What straining really does
Think of whey as the watery part of yogurt. When you strain it off, what’s left is more concentrated in solids—especially protein—and typically lower in lactose and total carbohydrates. That’s why Greek and skyr feel dense on the spoon and often taste a little tangier (1) (2) (3).
Straining also affects minerals. Remove more whey after fermentation and you’ll send some dissolved calcium out with it, so Greek often shows a lower calcium number than traditional. Some brands add calcium back, so label-reading wins (1) (3).
Regular vs. Greek vs. Skyr: A Quick Comparison
Here’s what to look for at a glance—then we’ll go deeper.
- Protein: Nonfat Greek (~170 g/6 oz) ≈ ~17 g; typical plain low-fat regular yogurt (8 fl oz) ≈ 12.9 g; skyr varies by brand but is generally high due to extensive straining—check your label (4) (5) (3).
- Lactose/carbs: Strained styles (Greek/skyr) generally contain less lactose and carbohydrate than unstrained styles because whey is removed (1) (2).
- Calcium: Regular often retains a bit more; Greek can be lower post-straining (brand-dependent) (1) (2) (3).
- Texture/taste: Regular = looser, milder; Greek = thick, tangy; skyr = ultra-thick, often a little milder than Greek (culture-dependent) (1) (3).
Deep dives (So You Can Buy With Confidence)
Regular yogurt
What it is: Fermented milk with live cultures; lightly strained or unstrained (1).
Why people pick it: A softer, more pourable texture and milder flavor. Because less whey is removed, regular yogurt often shows a higher calcium number than strained styles—but compare brands(1) (3).
Numbers to know: A plain low-fat cup (8 fl oz) averages ~12.86 g protein, ~154 kcal, and ~448 mg calcium (5).
Greek yogurt
What it is: Yogurt strained more thoroughly to remove whey, yielding a thicker texture with concentrated protein and generally less lactose/carbs than regular (1) (2).
Why people pick it: High protein for satiety and a creamy body that works as a dip base or a dollop on savory dishes. Some people with lactose intolerance tolerate it better than milk (2) (6)
Numbers to know: A plain nonfat ~170 g (6 oz) serving averages ~17 g protein and ~100 kcal (4).
Label heads-up: “Greek-style” may mean thickened rather than strained; protein grams and ingredient lists tell the real story (1).
Skyr (Icelandic style)
What it is: A concentrated cultured dairy product in the same family as strained yogurts; historically made very thick via straining/filtration, similar in principle to Greek (3).
Why people pick it: Even thicker than many Greek yogurts and typically high in protein because of the extensive concentration step; exact protein varies by brand—check the panel (3).
Lactose note: As with Greek, straining removes some lactose; many lactose-sensitive folks do better with strained styles, but tolerance is personal (2) (6) .
Pro tip: “If you are sensitive to lactose, test tolerance with a few spoonfuls of plain Greek or skyr alongside a meal. Track symptoms in your notes—you’ll learn fast what works for you,” says Gregg.
How to choose based on your goals
A couple of smart label checks go a long way.
For higher protein and fullness:
Look for single-serve cups with ≥10 grams of protein; Greek and many skyr options hit this easily. Log your protein in MyFitnessPal to see how one cup moves your daily total (4) (3).
If you’re lactose-sensitive:
Start with strained styles (Greek/skyr), choose plain, and keep portions modest at first. Many people with lactose intolerance tolerate yogurt better than milk; individual tolerance varies (1) (2) (6)
If you’re watching added sugars:
Plain wins. Sweetness from fruit, spices, and a light drizzle of honey is a healthier carbohydrate option than the sugar in flavored cups. Watch the Added Sugars line on the label and choose products with less added sugars for better health benefits. (1).
If calcium is your priority:
Because more whey is retained, regular yogurt often shows a bit more calcium than strained styles—though some Greek/skyr products are fortified. Compare the %DV on the panel (1) (3).
“My three-step yogurt check: protein grams first, added sugars second, then fat content,” says Gregg. “Once that’s dialed in, pick the texture and toppings you love and you’re more likely to stick with it.”
What to scan on the label (save this for your next shop)
- Protein target: For a filling snack, aim for ≥10 g per single-serve cup (4).
- Added sugars: Prefer 0 g added sugars in plain; flavored cups vary widely (1).
- Live cultures wording: Look for “live and active cultures.” Probiotic effects are strain- and condition-specific—don’t assume all cultured foods act the same (1)(7).
- Fat level: Nonfat, low-fat, or whole—choose what fits your personal goals. (2).
Frequently Asked Questions: Greek vs Regular vs Skyr
Is Greek always better than regular?
Not across the board. Greek is usually higher in protein and lower in lactose/carbs because of straining; regular often retains a bit more calcium and has a milder flavor. The “best” pick depends on your goals—and the exact brand in your hand (1) (2) (3).
Is skyr just Greek yogurt by another name?
They’re close cousins: both are concentrated/strained cultured dairy products. Skyr is traditionally very thick and high in protein because of how extensively it’s concentrated, but specifics differ by culture and brand (3).
Do all yogurts have probiotics?
Most list “live and active cultures,” but probiotic benefits depend on strain and use case. A high CFU claim or extra strains isn’t a guarantee of a specific health effect (1)(7).
The Bottom Line
When it comes to yogurt, regular, Greek, and skyr all earn a spot in a healthy pattern. The main difference is mostly how much they’re strained. Let your goals drive the pick: reach for Greek or skyr when you want more protein and (often) lower lactose, or choose regular if you prefer a milder taste and potentially more calcium. Compare labels—protein grams, added sugars, calcium %DV, and “live & active cultures”—then pick the texture you’ll actually enjoy. Track your cup in MyFitnessPal so what you love lines up with what you need.
The post Yogurt Aisle Decoder: Greek vs. Regular vs. Skyr appeared first on MyFitnessPal Blog.