What Matters Most In Attraction?

We are a professional review company that receives compensation from companies whose products we review. We test each product thoroughly and give high marks only to the ones that are the very best. We are independently owned, and the opinions expressed here are our own.

The Myth That Never Dies

In more than a decade of coaching men and women about dating and relationships, one debate always comes back like clockwork:

“It’s all about looks.”

Usually, that statement comes from younger men who are frustrated with modern dating apps or feel invisible in the algorithm.
I get it — it’s easy to believe attraction is purely visual when everything online reduces people to photos and bios.

But real connection doesn’t work that way.
When you zoom out — beyond short-term attraction and into lasting relationships — the evidence tells a very different story.

The Science of Attraction — It Starts in the Brain, Not the Mirror

A 2024 study published in Sexuality & Culture by Abé introduced the idea of “sexual priors.”
It suggests our brains hold internal templates — mental reference points shaped by both biology and life experience — that determine what feels attractive to us.

These priors aren’t limited to physical features. They include emotional familiarity, voice tone, scent, energy, and learned associations from our past.
In other words, your sense of attraction is as much about who someone reminds you of emotionally as how they look.

So yes, appearance can spark attraction, but what keeps it alive comes from something far deeper and more personal — a match between internal emotional patterns.

Looks open the door; compatibility invites you inside.

The Role of Looks — Important but Overrated

Let’s be honest: physical attraction matters.
Without it, relationships often turn platonic. But the key is that it appears to function as a filter, not a foundation.

Meta-analyses such as Langlois et al. (2000) have shown that physical attractiveness influences initial interest — but once real interaction begins, other traits, such as warmth, humor, trustworthiness, and emotional intelligence, take over.

That’s why you sometimes see an “average-looking” couple with extraordinary chemistry.
What’s happening isn’t a mystery — it’s emotional attunement.

Money and Status — Attractive Signals, Weak Glue

Another myth I hear constantly:

“Women only care about money or job title.”

In reality, status and income act as signals of stability, but they don’t sustain desire.
I’ve coached men with six-figure salaries who couldn’t maintain a relationship for more than a month — and others with modest incomes who built decades of partnership.

Studies like Finkel & Eastwick (2008) show that when people actually interact, personality and emotional responsiveness quickly outweigh external traits.
Confidence might catch attention, but consistency earns trust.

Why Emotional Attraction Matters More Than Ever

A 2024 study in the Journal of Sex Research looked at 227 couples where one partner had Sexual Interest/Arousal Disorder (SIAD).
It found that daily attraction toward one’s partner was directly linked to higher sexual satisfaction and desire for both partners.
When attraction rose, distress dropped.

The takeaway?
Attraction to who your partner is — their presence, humor, emotional warmth — has measurable effects on desire and satisfaction, even when physical factors fluctuate.

And it changes day by day, showing that attraction isn’t something you “own”; it’s something you renew through shared connection.

What Women Actually Respond To — and Why Men Misread It

Women don’t test men to play games.
They test how emotionally stable a man is — whether he can stay calm, grounded, and self-assured under pressure.
They’re not measuring your wallet; they’re reading your nervous system.

If she feels emotionally safe around you, attraction deepens — even if you’re not her “type.”
If she doesn’t, no amount of status or aesthetics can compensate.

She’s not checking your bank account; she’s checking if she can trust her heart around you.

Experience Teaches What Youth Can’t

Older couples rarely talk about appearance when asked why they’ve lasted.
They mention humor, patience, shared values, and the ability to communicate during conflict.
The spark that drew them together changed shape — but it never disappeared, because it was built on emotional reliability, not surface traits.

So What Really Creates Lasting Attraction?

1. Emotional Attunement — feeling seen and understood.
2. Reliability — words and actions that align.
3. Shared Values — a sense of “we” instead of “me.”

Combine those with genuine physical chemistry, and you get something rare: attraction that deepens instead of decays.

Final Thoughts — Beyond the Mirror

Looks may get you noticed.
But depth — empathy, humor, and emotional safety — are what make someone remember you long after the first glance fades.

Attraction built on dopamine burns bright and fast.
Attraction built on depth glows for years.

If you want to see how these myths play out in real life, I break them down in my video “3 Myths About Looks, Money and Status” — and why believing them keeps people single.

📚 References & Suggested Reading

For readers who’d like to explore the research mentioned in this article, here are some key peer-reviewed studies you can access for more profound insight.

Abé, H. (2024). The concept of innate sexual priors in the brain: A theory on why we are attracted to what we are attracted to.
Sexuality & Culture. Springer.

Conroy, N. E., Milhausen, R. R., & Herbenick, D. (2024). Attraction toward one’s partner is associated with sexual desire, satisfaction, and distress among couples coping with sexual interest/arousal disorder.
Journal of Sex Research. Taylor & Francis.

Langlois, J. H., Kalakanis, L., Rubenstein, A. J., Larson, A., Hallam, M., & Smoot, M. (2000). Maxims or myths of beauty? A meta-analytic and theoretical review.
Psychological Bulletin, 126(3), 390–423.

Finkel, E. J., & Eastwick, P. W. (2008). Speed-dating studies of romantic attraction: What have we learned?
Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 2(3), 1497–1510.

Sprecher, S., & Regan, P. C. (2002). Liking some things (in some people) more than others: Partner preferences in romantic relationships and friendships.
Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 19(4), 463–481.