AT&T’s “guarantee” gets a reality check from ad regulators
If you’ve watched a lot of TV lately, you’ve probably seen AT&T‘s big ad campaign promising “the connectivity you depend on… or we’ll make it right.” Well, competitor Charter Communications (the company behind Spectrum) wasn’t buying it and filed a complaint with the National Advertising Division (NAD), an industry watchdog.
After reviewing the ads, the NAD came back with a split decision. The more emotional, vague commercials were given a pass, as the NAD figured most people understand a “guarantee” has fine print. However, the ads that ran during March Madness, which specifically promised “Network interruptions fixed fast,” were flagged as misleading.
The NAD pointed out that the guarantee only kicks in after a wireless outage lasts 20 minutes or an internet outage lasts 60 minutes, which isn’t exactly “fast.” The watchdog also told AT&T to stop claiming it was the “first and only” carrier to offer such a guarantee, as it couldn’t prove it.
This is more than just a slap on the wrist
Screen grab from the AT&T March Madness ad. | Image credit — Rebellium TV
This ruling is a classic example of the fierce competition between carriers. Charter is constantly looking for ways to poke holes in AT&T‘s marketing, and vice-versa. In this case, it found a weak spot.
The ruling forces AT&T to be more transparent about what its big promises actually mean for customers. A guarantee that only activates after your connection has been down for up to an hour isn’t the simple safety net the commercials make it out to be.
Fine print always wins, doesn’t it?
Carrier advertising is definitely a battlefield of grand promises and nearly invisible disclosures, so I’m not surprised the “fixed fast” claim got AT&T in trouble. In my experience, when your internet goes out, no amount of time feels “fast.” The fact that you have to wait for a significant outage before the “guarantee” even starts its clock makes the whole thing feel a bit hollow.
This ruling doesn’t necessarily change my opinion on the quality of AT&T‘s actual network, but it definitely makes me more skeptical of its marketing slogans. It’s a perfect reminder of the golden rule for any tech or service purchase: ignore the flashy commercials and read the terms and conditions. A “guarantee” is only as good as the exceptions it lists, and it turns out AT&T‘s has some pretty big ones.
“Iconic Phones” is coming this Fall!
Rediscover some of the most unique and memorable phones of the last two decades! “Iconic Phones” is a beautifully illustrated book that we’ve been working on for over a year – and it’s coming out in just a couple short month!